Every November, online education marketers make the same mistake: they increase their Google Ads budgets during Black Friday and Cyber Monday, expecting a flood of new enrollments. Then they watch CPCs spike, budgets evaporate, and revenue disappoint.
We analyzed one client’s BFCM performance to understand why this approach fails for high-consideration purchases like courses and certificates. What we found will change how you think about BFCM planning.
Why BFCM Strategy Differs for Online Education
Unlike low-consideration impulse purchases, online courses & certificates often require longer consideration periods. Price matters—many of our clients’ courses are $1,000 or more. But potential students aren’t just evaluating cost. They’re evaluating the time commitment required to complete the course and whether they’ll actually follow through. For many people, this commitment of time is what stretches out the period of consideration before they decide to enroll. By way of analogy, it’s far more likely for someone to spontaneously spend $1k to upgrade their television (no time commitment other than swapping it in for the old one) than it is for them to do the same with a $1k online course that will require many hours of their future attention and energy to complete.
Our analysis of client data consistently shows buyer journeys spanning weeks or even months from first click to purchase. This extended decision-making process fundamentally changes how online education programs should approach BFCM.
This isn’t just about attribution modeling—it’s about understanding how acquisition systems work for high-consideration purchases. The feedback loop between early awareness touchpoints (non-brand search) and late-stage conversion channels (email, retargeting) takes weeks to complete. Optimizing campaigns in isolation during BFCM ignores this reality.
What the Data Actually Tell Us
We analyzed BFCM 2024 performance for a client running a seven-day promotion in late November and early December. Here’s what we discovered:
The Time-to-Purchase Reality
Using Google Ads’ Path Metrics report, we discovered that more than half of the revenue Google Ads generated during BFCM came from users whose first interaction with our client’s ads occurred more than a week before their purchase.
While this finding indicates the need to broaden the scope of BFCM planning, things become even clearer when looking at branded vs. non-branded search and evaluating Google Ads’ role as a discovery channel.
The Attribution Story
When we examined client data in TripleWhale using first-click attribution, Google Ads search campaigns contributed $81,000 in revenue during the seven-day sale period. Of that total, $34,000 (42%) came from non-branded search campaigns—people who likely hadn’t heard of the brand before encountering our client’s ads.
Here’s the critical insight: of that $34,000, only $3,000 came from users whose first visit occurred during the sale itself. The reality is: if you’re waiting until BFCM to attract new potential customers, you’ve likely already missed the boat.
The contrast with last-touch attribution is equally telling. Using last-touch attribution, those same non-brand search campaigns accounted for only 10% of Google Ads revenue during the sale. Allocating more budget to these campaigns during the week of Thanksgiving means spending more per click (due to elevated CPCs during this week of intense ad buying competition) to show ads to people who aren’t ready to make a high-consideration purchase that, to be truly valuable, requires significant future time and energy investment. Put simply, the important “consideration” part of this purchase just doesn’t happen so quickly for most people.
Why Increasing BFCM Budgets Backfires
Here’s what actually happens when you increase non-brand search budgets during BFCM week:
- You pay 40-60% more per click due to increased competition
- You attract cold prospects who aren’t ready to buy (and have now set their pricing expectations based on likely your lowest prices of the year)
- You compete with retailers offering instant gratification purchases
- Your CAC spikes while conversion rates plummet
Meanwhile, your best prospects—the ones who discovered you in September and October—are sitting in your email list, ready to convert.
The Multi-Channel View
Zooming out from just Google Ads, we’re able to see the role different channels play during BFCM. While paid search is the biggest revenue driver from a first-click perspective, the top-performing channel when looking at last-click attribution is email. This shouldn’t come as a surprise, as your email audience is likely further along in the consideration process and already familiar with your brand.
What This Means for Your BFCM Strategy
These findings point to two strategic imperatives for online education businesses:
1. Non-branded search drives BFCM revenue—but weeks before the sale
These campaigns play a crucial role in BFCM success, but their primary contribution happens in the weeks and months before the sale. It’s your top-of-funnel engine, introducing new potential students to your offerings and starting them on their consideration journey.
2. During BFCM itself, focus on re-engaging your existing audience
When the actual sale days arrive, your budget and energy are better allocated to channels that target people already in your funnel: email campaigns, organic social media posts, and Google Ads retargeting.
The Right Time to Increase Your Google Ads Spend
To maximize BFCM revenue, don’t wait until November to ramp up your non-brand Google Ads campaigns. Start building your pipeline in September and October. Give potential students time to discover your offerings, research their options, and move through their consideration phase.
Then, when BFCM arrives and you launch your promotion, you’ll have a qualified audience that has already considered your course and is primed to convert. This audience is reached most effectively through email and retargeting, not cold acquisition campaigns.
This data-driven approach aligns your ad spend with actual buyer behavior in the online education space, rather than following retail playbooks that don’t account for longer sales cycles.
The Strategic Shift
If you’re planning for next year’s BFCM, flip your thinking: invest in non-brand acquisition in Q3 to build your pipeline, then shift budget to email and retargeting during the sale itself.
This approach requires something most agencies don’t offer: the ability to connect campaign performance with actual customer journey data. Without that feedback loop between your ad platform and your enrollment data, you’re flying blind.
Want to see how this approach could work for your program? Request a consultation to discuss your customer acquisition strategy.
